Cream Teas and Afternoon Tea are available by reservation Tuesday to Saturday from 12:30 PM to 4 PM. For “day of” reservations, please call 772-492-3614, otherwise we recommend following our online booking procedure. Our facility is open for private tea parties on Sundays, subject to availability.
Prices are per person with a minimum of two persons per party; individual tea servings are not available for sharing. Tea and Scones may be taken any time while we are open (until we sell out of scones); there is no minimum number of persons required. To choose your sandwiches from our full selection, please use our online booking form.
How Afternoon Tea Works
Cream Tea, Afternoon Tea, High Tea…. How does it all work? See below for High Tea which has nothing to do with finger sandwiches, scones, and killing time (and appetite) between breakfast and dinner.
The tiers in our menu descriptions refer to the number of plates in the cake stands. By tradition, one starts from the bottom of the stand and works upwards. The bottom tier is always finger sandwiches; the second tier is scones, clotted cream and jam; the third tier consists of mini desserts and a slice of cake, usually Victoria Sponge.
OUR CREAM TEA AND AFTERNOON TEA MENU
- “Two Tier” Cream Tea Per Person Serving: Finger Sandwiches (Two Pieces Each of Three Sandwiches Per Person), A Freshly Made Tea Scone (Fruit or Plain), Jam, Real Devonshire Clotted Cream, Small Pot of Loose Leaf Tea. $24.95 per person.
- “Three Tier” Afternoon Tea Per Person Serving: Finger Sandwiches (Two Pieces Each of Four Sandwiches Per Person)Freshly Made Tea Scone (Fruit or Plain), Jam, Real Devonshire Clotted Cream; Three Mini Desserts Such as French Macarons, Petits Fours, and Mini Cakes, Slice of Victoria Sponge Cake; Small Pot of Loose Leaf Tea $42.95 per person.
- Children’s Tea (12 years and younger) Finger Sandwiches (Four pieces of finger sandwiches. Choose two from Organic Egg Salad, Cream Cheese and Cucumber, or Peanut Butter and Jelly); Freshly Made Tea Scone (Fruit or Plain), Jam, Real Devonshire Clotted Cream; Small Pot of Loose Leaf Tea, Orange Juice or Almond Milk $14.95 per person
Finger Sandwich Choices
Cheddar Cheese and Branston Pickle
Cream Cheese and Cucumber
Cucumber and Irish Butter
Organic Egg Salad
Pimento Cheese and Ham
Roast Beef with Horseradish Cream
Roast Beef with Housemade Tomato Jam
Smoked Salmon with Irish Butter (Seasonal)
Turkey with Cranberry Aioli
Add a glass of Prosecco to any Tea for $12 per person. Sandwich fillings and desserts are subject to change. To choose your sandwiches from an even larger selection, please use our online booking form.
For special dietary requirements such as a vegan tea or gluten free, please call us at 772-492-3614.
The Difference Between High Tea and Afternoon Tea
Many people refer to Cream Tea and Afternoon Tea as High Tea. This is generally a misinterpretation of how the tradition of Afternoon Tea evolved. While the Duchess of Bedford (the attributed creator of Afternoon Tea) was entertaining her friends at a “low” table with finger sandwiches, scones, and pastries in the afternoon, her servants were hoping she would finish soon and leave some scones. They would finish work and sit down to their tea at a “high” table. The meal would consist of a hot dish, a pot of tea and something sweet. High Tea was traditionally taken later in the evening, around 6 PM. In keeping with our British tradition, Sealantro will be adding a High Tea to the menu in the near future. In the meantime, polish your tea knowledge badge and come see us for Cream Tea or Afternoon Tea.